Nothing makes a good day better than a dollop of ice cream. Luckily, ice cream is not off the menu when you have diabetes. One delicious option is Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream, a low-carb frozen dessert without added sugar.

Here’s the scoop on why Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream is good for people with diabetes.

Key Takeaways

  • Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream uses sweeteners that don’t spike blood sugar.
  • It contains 16–21 grams of carbs per serving, lower net carbs.
  • It is better than regular ice cream because it has less sugar, calories, and carbs.
  • For portion control, stick to a half-cup serving pair with protein and fiber.
  • As a person with diabetes, always pick an ice cream with <20 grams of carbs, low sugar, and high fiber.
  • Try Halo Top, Edy’s Slow Churned, and Blue Bunny for diabetic-friendly choices.

Is Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream Diabetic-Friendly?

Breyers Carb Smart is a sweet treat that can fit right into your meal plan .

Firstly, it has no refined sugars, which are linked to type 2 diabetes. To give it a rich, creamy taste, it uses a combination of these sweeteners instead:

  • Maltitol syrup: low-calorie sugar alcohol without an unpleasant aftertaste
  • Acesulfame potassium: a zero-calorie artificial sweetener 
  • Sucralose: a calorie-free artificial sweetener that’s less sweet than acesulfame potassium

These sugar substitutes are sweeter than table sugar—a little goes a long way—and they have little to no impact on blood sugar levels when consumed in moderation.

Large amounts of sugar and alcohol can irritate the gut, so keep your portions down.   

Another reason Breyers Carb Smart is worth a try is that it has fewer carbohydrates than most ice creams.

That said, how the body reacts to food varies from person to person. Check your blood sugar readings after eating your ice cream to ensure you’re well within your target.

How Many Carbs Are In Breyers Smart Carb Ice Cream?

The amount of carbs slightly varies among different ice cream flavors. Here’s a glance at all the Breyers carb-conscious options and their carb content:

  • Vanilla: 16 grams
  • Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry: 16 grams
  • Chocolate Flavor: 17 grams
  • Chocolate Chip: 19 grams
  • Mint Chip: 19 grams
  • Mint Fudge Cookie: 20 grams
  • Brownie a La Mode: 21 grams

The American Diabetes Association now approves a low-carb diet to help manage diabetes. A personalized eating plan with a consistent, pre-set carbohydrate count is crucial to effective blood sugar control.

The best way to stick to your carb budget while enjoying ice cream is to remove one carb-heavy food from your meal. For instance, you may skip pasta to make room for a serving of Breyers vanilla ice cream.

Top View Of Ice Cream In Cup

From a blood sugar perspective, pay attention to net carbs.

You get net carbs after subtracting dietary fibers and sugar alcohols, like erythritol and xylitol, from total carbs. They’re broken down into glucose, or blood sugar, which your body absorbs completely.

Lastly, follow the recommended serving size to watch your carbohydrate intake.

How Does Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream Compare to Regular Ice Cream?

Compared to regular ice cream, Breyers Carb Smart offers reduced sugar, calories, and carbohydrates. It contains artificial sweeteners and sugar alcohols that don’t spike blood sugar.

Traditional ice creams have high amounts of added sugar, such as corn syrup and cane sugar, which can cause weight gain and blood sugar spikes. They’re also rich in calories and carbs.

For example, regular vanilla ice cream from Breyers has 170 calories, 19 grams of sugar, 19 grams of carbs, and zero dietary fiber. More decadent flavors like Rocky Road and Chocolate Peanut Butter have even more.

A Woman Eating Ice Cream In Light Room

How to Enjoy Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream Safely as a Diabetic

Follow these tips to make every spoonful of your delicious ice cream guilt-free: 

  • Even with diabetes-friendly desserts, portion control is vital to maintaining stable blood sugar levels. Stick to a half-cup serving!
  • Pair ice cream with a protein and dietary fiber source, such as a small handful of nuts or beans. Lean protein and fiber-rich foods can help slow the absorption of sugar and control blood sugar spikes.
  • The body works more complexly processing sugar at night, so eat your ice cream earlier in the day.
  • It’s best to consume ice cream with a meal. That way, you can switch out foods to ensure you stay within your carb intake limit.
  • Enjoy your Breyers Carb Smart ice cream as an occasional treat or part of a balanced nutritional plan.

How to Choose the Best Ice Cream for Diabetics

Cookies And Cream Ice Cream

In moderation, ice cream can be part of a healthy diet. If you’re looking for diabetic-friendly ice cream, remember these tips when surfing the frozen aisles: 

  • Read nutrition labels and pay attention to how many grams of carbohydrates are in ice cream products. Choose a flavor that contains no more than 20 grams of carbs per half-cup serving.
  • Pick options with lower or no sugar content and high dietary fiber.
  • If you’re on a keto diet, choose low-carb ice cream with keto-friendly sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit. These natural sweeteners have a low glycemic index.
  • Fats slow down sugar absorption. Opt for keto ice cream, a low-carb option with higher fat content.
  • Look for sugar-free ice cream with the sugar alcohol erythritol. It’s gentler on the stomach than most other types.

Here are other ice cream brands to satisfy your sweet tooth while keeping your blood sugar levels in check:

  • Halo Top Vanilla Bean
  • Edy’s Slow Churned Ice Cream
  • Blue Bunny Ice Cream

Conclusion

So, is Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream suitable for people with diabetes?

The verdict is in—Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream is a delicious treat for people with diabetes. Its low sugar content, calorie count, and net carbs make it suitable for those looking for a sweet fix without guilt.

Just remember to enjoy all good things in moderation!

Consult a healthcare professional for dietary advice on managing your blood glucose levels.

Sources

At Diabetic Me, we are committed to delivering information that is precise, accurate, and pertinent. Our articles are supported by verified data from research papers, prestigious organizations, academic institutions, and medical associations to guarantee the integrity and relevance of the information we provide. You can learn more about our process and team on the about us page.

  1. CDC Diabetes Meal Planning
    Source: CDC
  2. American Diabetes Association Nutrition Therapy for Adults With Diabetes or Prediabetes: A Consensus Report
    Source: American Diabetes Association

6 Comments

  1. Karl V. on February 21, 2025

    hey, was reading the article by Inez Briand and got thinking, how does this carb smart ice cream really stack up against regular ice cream in taste? anybody tried both and can give a real comparison, not just the stats?

    Reply
    • Tammy F. on February 21, 2025

      I’ve tried the vanilla flavor, tastes just as good as regular to me! Pretty surprising.

      Reply
    • Gus W. on February 21, 2025

      Taste is subjective, man. But it’s decent, especially if you’re watching your carbs.

      Reply
  2. xxSpikeDogxx on April 1, 2024

    so everyone’s acting like this Breyers stuff is gonna change the game huh? i mean its ice cream, people. how good for you can ice cream be, diabetic or not. cant believe people just eat up this stuff (pun intended lol). Anyone else think the sugar alcohols gonna mess ya up more than sugar?

    Reply
  3. MarlaT on March 1, 2024

    hey Inez Briand, I read about Breyers Carb Smart and gotta ask, how accurate is the carb count on these? My hubby’s really gotta watch his levels and I wanna make sure this is safe for him. do u think its a good switch from regular ice cream?

    Reply
    • GinaBee on April 5, 2024

      MarlaT, the carb counts are usually pretty accurate on those labels. If you’re cautious, start with small servings and check his blood sugar to see how he responds. It’s a decent alternative to regular ice cream, just monitor the sugar alcohols.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

About the Author

Inez Briand

As the partner of a type 1 diabetic, my passion for healthy cooking has reached new heights. I’ve always loved traveling and experimenting in the kitchen, but now I focus on creating delicious, diabetes-friendly recipes for my partner, Ely, and our family. Through Diabetic Me, I enjoy sharing food and nutrition tips to help others on their journey toward healthier living.

View All Articles